Winner
Tim Brzakala
Nominees
Cain McMillan
Jeremy Adams
Caleb Boatman
Dominic Rizzi
Jake Maringoni
Thomas Scully
Eli McCaig
Nicholas Twohig

Winner:
Jake Maringoni
Nominees:
Jeremy Adams
Caleb Boatman
Brian Michaels
Dominic Rizzi

Winner:
None*
Nominees:
Jeremy Adams
Maggie Brzakala
Tim Brzakala
Rene Villareal, Jr.

*Award Removed

Winner:
The Concept…
Nominees:
Apokalips Now
Blockbuster Video
Second Reel
Team 80’s

Winner:
Arkham Knights
Nominees:
Dedicated 2 Art
Necronomicon
Kings of Winter
Ragnarok

Winner:
Alec Miller
Nominees:
Jim Green
Kaleb Koho
Eli McCaig
Tim Smith
Zaddeus Smith
Brooklyn Vail

Winner:
Thomas Scully
Nominees:
Michael Campbell
Jim Green
Russell Howell
Cody Newberry
Sandy Robinson
Lucas Schildbach

Winner:
Tim Brzakala
Nominees:
Jay Burnz
Nazario Montenegro
Kaleb Koho
Robert Parker

Winner:
Caleb Boatman
Nominees:
Jacoby Bancroft
Andrew Barr
Ethan Beller
Antonio Chavez
Cameron Holzmann
Kirk Kowalkowski

Winner:
Maggie Brzakala
Nominees:
Caleb Boatman
Mark Camire
Cameron Holzmann
Thomas Scully
Nicholas Twohig
Albert Wiradharma

Winner:
Mischief Managed
Nominees:
Dedicated 2 Art
*insert name here*
Komodo Dragons
Necronomicon
Nick of Time
Ragnarok

Winner:
The Concept…
Nominees:
The Clash at Demonhead
Con of the Dead
Cult Classics
Light it Up
Scruffy Looking Nerf Herders
Second Reel

Winner:
Jake Maringoni vs Ethan Beller
Nominees:
Apokalips Now vs Team 80’s
Caleb Boatman vs Dominic Rizzi
Caleb Boatman vs Jeremy Adams
The Concept… vs Team 2319
Dominic Rizzi vs Brian Michaels
Jeremy Adams vs Brian Michaels
Jeremy Adams vs Jake Maringoni II
Wyld Stallyns vs Blockbuster Video

Winner:
Robert Parker vs Tim Brzakala
Nominees:
Arkham Knights vs Dedicated 2 Art
Caleb Boatman vs Thomas Scully
Caleb Boatman vs Dominic Rizzi
Kings of Winter vs Arkham Knights
Maggie Brzakala vs Dominic Rizzi
Nicholas Twohig vs Ruben Colon
Nick of Time vs Midsommar Nightmare
Maggie Brzakala vs Tim Brzakala

Winner:
Tim Brzakala vs Robert Parker
Nominees:
Cain McMillan vs Robert Parker
Doug Cassel vs Caleb Boatman vs Tony Heald
Tim Brzakala vs Kaleb Koho
Ruben Colon vs Mark Camire vs Jacoby Bancroft

Winner:
Maggie Brzakala beats Dominic Rizzi (Fandom)
Nominees:
Blockbuster Video beats Wyld Stallyns (Melee)
Clash at Demonhead beats Strange Brew (Melee)
Ethan Beller beats Jake Maringoni (Melee)
Nazario Montenegro beats Sean Sandberg (Melee)
Richard Schwartz beats Jeremy Adams (Fandom)
Scruffy Looking Nerf Herders beats Jurassic Sharks (Melee)

Winner:
Maggie Brzakala
Nominees:
Jeremy Adams
Jacoby Bancroft
Andrew Barr
Caleb Boatman
Cameron Holzmann
Nicholas Twohig

Winner:
Cody Newberry
Nominees:
Eli Boatman
Tim Brzakala
Jim Green
Kaleb Koho
Dominic Rizzi
Lucas Schildbach

Winner:
Cody Newberry
Nominees:
Thomas Eanes
Joe Harrison
Kaleb Koho
Nico Suave Regoli
Adelaide Spence
Brooklyn Vail

Winner:
Blockbuster Video
Nominees:
Apokalips Now
Cult Classics
*insert name here*
Team 80’s

Winner:
Kings of Winter
Nominees:
Team 2319
The Clash at Demonhead
F You Lucas
Ragnarok

Winner:
Jake Maringoni
Nominees:
Michael Campbell
Thomas Eanes
Nazario Montenegro
Dominic Rizzi

Winner:
Tim Brzakala
Nominees:
Jay Burnz
Nico Suave Regoli
Cain McMillan
Rene Villareal, Jr.

Winner:
Jake Maringoni becomes Double-Belted
Nominees:
Ambush
Maggie beats Rizzi
Then I Win
Triceratops
Welcome to Mooseport

Winner:
Brian Michaels (vs Dominic Rizzi)
Nominees:
Arkham Knights (vs Dedicated 2 Art)
Caleb Boatman (vs Jeremy Adams)
Kaleb Koho (vs Corey Quinto)
Thomas Eanes (vs Apokalips Now)